Is Guitar Hero Better Than Rock Band?

You could win a Cool Mystery Prize for voting!


Guitar Hero!
Rock Band!


Guitar Hero!
Rock Band!















In a Boston office with a Fender Strat leaning against the wall, Eric Brosius, a sound designer for video-game developer Harmonix, is staring at clusters of tiny blue bars on his computer screen: Keith Moon's madman drum part from "Won't Get Fooled Again," as mapped out note for note by an on-staff musician. The company that developed Guitar Hero has spent the past year transforming that song and dozens of others -- from the Rolling Stones' "Gimme Shelter" to Metallica's "Enter Sandman" -- into playable pieces of its new music game, Rock Band. Soon, players will be furiously banging electronic drum pads to replicate Moon's stickwork, mashing buttons on guitar-shaped controllers to match Pete Townshend's and John Entwistle's parts, and even trying to scream "Yeeeah!" at the right moment into a microphone. "You get to experience what it's like to play every single part of 'Won't Get Fooled Again' and to see how the parts interact," says Eran Egozy, who co-founded Harmonix as a graduate student at MIT.

Guitar Hero may well be this decade's biggest rock & roll phenomenon. Guitar Hero I and II have grossed $360 million since the first game came out in 2005 -- vastly more than any album released in the same period. And the games -- in which players re-create songs' guitar parts by pushing buttons that correspond to notes and chords while hitting a "strum bar" in rhythm -- have inspired kids by the millions to memorize the intricacies of "Free Bird" and "War Pigs." One measure of the games' clout: MTV purchased Harmonix for $175 million last year, and video-game giant Activision paid $99.9 million to acquire RedOctane, the company that owns the Guitar Hero name and manufactured the game's guitar- shaped controllers.

With MTV and Activision unwilling or unable to collaborate, the franchise's future has split in two: Activision's Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock -- a straightforward sequel with a few twists, including a new "battle mode" -- hits stores October 28th, while Harmonix's Rock Band -- which adds drums and vocals to the formula -- comes out November 23rd. Analysts say that the market is big enough for both games to succeed (music games represent about eight percent of the U.S. video-game market, according to the research group NPD) -- so their near-simultaneous releases could become the music event of the year.

source



Related News

Guitar Hero: World Tour drums not Rock Band 2 compatible; Gene ...
Guitar Hero: World Tour has only officially been on shelves for a day or so now, but unhappy PS3 customers are already making a fuss -- the game's new drumkit isn't compatible with Rock Band 2. That's a major disappointment -- having ...
‘Guitar Hero’ And ‘Rock Band’ Fine Print: Activision ‘Prohibit’s ...
“Guitar Hero: World Tour” — out right now — and “AC/DC Live: Rock Band Track Pack” — coming on November 2 — mark some of first releases since we learned each set of instruments would work in their competition’s games. ...
GHWT drums don't work with Rock Band
If you're looking to buy Guitar Hero World Tour for the drumset, for use with Rock Band I or II, we've got some bad news. It won't work. Not sure why, we were promised, after all. Reports are that the games recognize the drum controller ...
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
Whether you are a KISS fan or not, you have to admit that this Rock Band and Guitar Hero compatible replica of his signature bass is just...plain...awesome. I know it is hard to look away, but if I could have your attention for just a ...
Use Of Rock Band Instruments With Guitar Hero "Expressly ...
Activision made kind of a big deal at E3 about Guitar Hero/Rock Band cross-compatibility. Said that, yes, you'd be able to use Rock Band instruments in Guitar Hero World Tour. But don't for a second think they're happy about it. ...
Guitar Hero: World Tour drums not recognized by PS3 Rock Band 2
Despite promises to the contrary, the PlayStation 3 Guitar Hero: World Tour drum set doesn't seem to be working with Rock Band 1 or 2. Many users on the RB forums have noticed that the game is recognizing the wireless set as a ...
Gene Simmons’ Battleaxe Guitar for Rock Band and Guitar Hero
Here’s something for those who like to paint their faces while playing Rock Band and Guitar Hero, after a healthy argument over the merits of belonging to the KISS army. Even if you aren’ta KISS fan, this is a badass Rock Band and ...
Guitar Hero World Tour Drums Reported Defective, Incompatible with ...
Meanwhile, as reported by Joystiq, posters at both Guitar Hero and Rock Band forums are reporting a slightly more uniform problem: the PS3 GHWT drums seem to be entirely incompatible with Rock Band 2, and show up as a USB microphone ...
Skwisgaar Tries Playing Guitar hero/ rock band
Show ID: 306418 Start at: 10/27/2008 4:51 pm PST Embed: http://www.ustream.tv/flash/live/306418 Description: im acceptionally good at gh.
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
Wouldn't it be great if there was a Guitar Hero/Rock Band version that featured a more realistic guitar neck that required kids to actually finger the true chord progressions? Then they might, you know, actually learn how to play a real ...
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
If I were a big enough tard to actually waste my time playing Guitar Hero that would definitely be the axe for me. Thrillcekr.
Guitar Hero: World Tour drums not recognized by PS3 Rock Band 2
According to this Joystiq story, the PS3 version of Rock Band 2 doesn’t recognise Guitar Hero: World Tour’s drum set. This may sound trifling. In fact, it is. Unfortunately, SCEA specifically promised instruments from the bigger rhythm ...
Gene Simmons’ Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar ...
Whether you’re a KISS fan or not, you’ve to admit that this Rock Band and Guitar Hero compatible replica of his signature bass is just…plain…awesome. I know it is hard to look away, but if I could have your attention for just a moment ...
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
don't all guitar hero and rock band guitars have bi-directional strum bars and analog whammy bars? laxman15.
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
I've only played rock band and have a cheap guitar. What with the two sets of buttons? shamoononon has a hebetudinous dog.
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
@shamoononon has a hebetudinous dog: In Rock Band, the smaller set of buttons function normally until a solo. Then they can play notes, without having to strum. It's useful for playing the very difficult solos, where the strum bar may ...
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
cool. now I can kill someone after playing Guitar Hero. :) Ultimate Finish! (just kidding) I would never kill anyone w/ a controller. colinv12.
Guitar Hero: World Tour drums not recognized by PS3 Rock Band 2
... href=http://www.joystiq.com/2008/10/27/guitar-hero-world-tour-drums-not-recognized-by-ps3-rock-band-2/Guitar Hero: World Tour drums not recognized by PS3 Rock Band 2/a originally appeared on a href=http://www.joystiq.comJoystiq/a on ...
Gene Simmons Axe for Guitar Hero and Rock Band! SWEET!
Compatible with both Guitar Hero and Rock Band. Bi-directional Strum Bar. Ultra Responsive Fret Buttons. Analog Whammy Bar. $79.99 to be released…ooooo aaaaaa Halloween, Oct 31! Pre-order now HERE! only for PS2 and 3 ...
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
@RaeCrisus: Thanks, that would be useful for me. I have a weak pinky finger, even though I use to play a real guitar. That actually looks like a much easier grip. shamoononon has a hebetudinous dog.
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
I really don't want my neighbors to look in my window and see me rocking Beth with this axe. AmishJohn.
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
i dont even have a console and still want it... Erzengel.
Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
Whether you are a KISS fan or not, you have to admit that this Rock Band and Guitar Hero compatible replica of his signature bass is just…plain…awesome. I found this on Kotaku and was like, yep, this is worth a post! ...
Gene Simmons' Badass Battleaxe Guitar For Rock Band and Guitar Hero
@kaiban: It'll be made out of plastic, and cost you an arm and a leg :P. Jon B.
Guitar Hero/Rock Band
I got both Rock Band 2 and Guitar Hero World Tour this weekend. Having a ton of fun in both. Who else out there is into these? I'll be happy to get together with anyone who wants to play a few songs every now and then. ...


Thank You For Your Vote!

Congratulations!

You were selected to receive the Cool Mystery Prize !

Simply enter your email address on the next page to claim your offer.

Thanks again for voting!